What Are The Cons Of Above Ground Pools?

Above ground pools are often promoted as an affordable and easy-to-install alternative to in-ground pools. While they offer certain benefits, such as portability and lower cost, there are also drawbacks that should be taken into consideration before making a purchase decision. In fact, the disadvantages of above ground pools can be significant enough to make them unsuitable for some homeowners.

As we explore the cons of above ground pools in this article, it is important to note that our goal is not to discourage anyone from buying or using these types of swimming facilities. Instead, our aim is to provide a balanced overview of the potential downsides so that readers can make informed choices based on their individual needs and preferences.

Whether you are planning to install an above ground pool for personal use or considering its impact on property value and aesthetics, it is important to have a clear understanding of both the pros and cons of this option.


Limited Durability of Above Ground Pools

The longevity of the aforementioned swimming pool type is constrained due to inherent physical limitations, which may be of concern to potential buyers. Above ground pools are typically made from materials such as steel, aluminum, or resin. While these materials are durable and can withstand regular use, they are not immune to wear and tear over time.

The constant exposure to water and chemicals can cause corrosion and rusting in metal components, while plastic parts may become brittle and crack. Installation challenges also contribute to the limited durability of above ground pools. These pools require a level surface for proper installation, which can be difficult to achieve without professional help.

Improper installation can lead to structural issues that compromise the integrity of the pool over time. Additionally, weather resistance is another factor that affects the lifespan of above ground pools. Extreme temperatures and harsh weather conditions such as heavy rain or snowfall can damage the pool’s structure or liner, leading to costly repairs or replacement.

Overall, while above ground pools offer an affordable alternative to in-ground options, their limited durability should be taken into consideration before making a purchase decision.

Potential for Damage and Repairs

The risk of damage and necessary repairs is a notable concern for those considering the installation of this popular backyard water feature. Above ground pools are not immune to damage, and anything from harsh weather conditions to accidental punctures can cause damage.

Additionally, the lifespan of an above ground pool is often shorter than that of in-ground pools, meaning pool owners might have to invest in costly repairs or replacements sooner rather than later.

Cost comparison is another factor that needs consideration when it comes to above ground pools. While they tend to be less expensive than in-ground options, the cost savings might not be worth it if constant repairs are needed.

Installation challenges can also arise with above ground pools, particularly if the area where it’s being installed isn’t level or has other obstacles. This means additional costs may be incurred during installation as homeowners will need to hire professionals who have experience installing above ground pools in challenging locations.

Ultimately, while there are many benefits to owning an above ground pool, potential buyers should carefully weigh their options and consider factors such as cost comparison and installation challenges before making a final decision.

Difficulty Maintaining and Cleaning

Maintaining and cleaning an above ground pool can be a daunting and time-consuming task. Water chemistry is essential to keeping the pool clean, clear, and safe for swimmers. The chemicals must be tested weekly or even daily during peak swimming season.

Balancing the pH level of the water is crucial to preventing algae growth and ensuring that chlorine is effective in killing bacteria. Failing to maintain proper chemical levels can result in a dirty and cloudy pool that can cause skin irritation, eye redness, and respiratory problems.

Moreover, filter maintenance is another vital aspect of keeping an above ground pool clean. Filters should be backwashed regularly to remove debris buildup that can clog them and reduce their efficiency in trapping dirt particles from the water.

In addition to regular maintenance tasks, weather and environmental factors can also impact pool cleanliness. Windy conditions may blow leaves, twigs, pollen into the water while heavy rains may wash soil or mud into the pool causing it to turn murky with sediment buildup at the bottom. Therefore, owning an above-ground pool requires a commitment of both time and money towards its upkeep if you want it to remain clean throughout its lifespan.

Lack of Built-In Features

One issue that may deter potential pool buyers is the absence of convenient built-in features in some above-ground pool models. Unlike in-ground pools, which can be customized to include various features such as waterfalls, slides and diving boards, above-ground pools tend to lack these additional elements. This can be a major drawback for those who are looking to have a pool that is not only functional but also aesthetically pleasing.

Furthermore, the installation process of an above-ground pool can also limit customization options. While there are several models available with various sizes and shapes, the overall design tends to be standardized. Additionally, certain features like decking or landscaping around the pool may require additional work and expenses.

Thus, it is important for potential buyers to consider their desired level of customization and weigh it against the limitations of an above-ground pool before making a purchase decision.

Need for Additional Equipment and Chemicals

To ensure proper water maintenance and safety, owning a pool of any type requires the use of additional equipment and chemicals. This is also true for above ground pools, which may require more equipment due to their lack of built-in features.

In addition to regular cleaning and chlorination, owners may have to invest in a filtration system, pool cover, and testing kit. These costs can add up quickly and become a significant financial burden for some homeowners.

Furthermore, the need for additional equipment and chemicals has an environmental impact. Chemicals used in pool maintenance can be harmful if not disposed of properly or if they enter the water supply through runoff. Additionally, the energy required to operate filtration systems contributes to carbon emissions that contribute to climate change.

Homeowners must consider these cost implications and environmental impacts before deciding whether an above ground pool is right for them.

Limited Size and Capacity

The limited size and capacity of above ground pools can be a hindrance for some individuals. Although they are available in various sizes, they still cannot compete with the larger in-ground pool options. This may restrict the number of people who can use them at once, making it an important consideration for those with larger families or who frequently entertain guests. Furthermore, these pools have weight restrictions that should be taken into account when installing them. Installation concerns must also be considered as they require level ground and proper support to maintain their structural integrity.

Budget constraints are also associated with above ground pools as they may not be the cheapest option available despite being more affordable than in-ground alternatives. However, there will still be additional costs incurred such as installation fees, water supply charges, and regular maintenance costs. The cost of buying additional equipment such as ladders and pumps should also be factored into the overall budget. It is important to remember that cheaper options may result in lower quality materials and weaker structures which may require costly repairs or replacements down the line.

Therefore, when considering purchasing an above ground pool it is essential to consider both its size limitations and potential budget constraints before making a decision.

Aesthetics and Property Value Considerations

While limited size and capacity are notable drawbacks of above ground pools, there are other factors to consider before investing in one. One such factor is the impact on your property’s aesthetics and resale value.

Above ground pools may not be as visually appealing as their in-ground counterparts, which can detract from the overall appearance of your landscaping. Additionally, some potential homebuyers may view an above ground pool as a temporary or less desirable addition to a property.

The landscaping impact of an above ground pool can be significant. The large structure can take up valuable yard space and may require additional fencing or decking for safety purposes. Furthermore, the installation process can disrupt existing plants and vegetation, leaving behind a less attractive area once the pool is in place.

When it comes time to sell your home, an above ground pool may also negatively affect its resale value. Some buyers may be willing to pay more for a property with an in-ground pool, while others may see an above ground pool as an eyesore that they would need to remove at their own expense.

Ultimately, homeowners should weigh these factors carefully before deciding whether or not to install an above ground pool on their property.


Above ground pools may seem like an attractive option, but they come with a range of disadvantages that should be considered before making a purchase. Firstly, the limited durability and potential for damage mean that above ground pools are prone to wear and tear, resulting in costly repairs.

Secondly, maintaining and cleaning an above ground pool can be difficult due to their lack of built-in features and need for additional equipment and chemicals.

Furthermore, above ground pools have a limited size and capacity compared to in-ground pools. Aesthetics should also be taken into consideration as they may not add value to your property or blend well with the surrounding landscape. Despite their initial affordability, the long-term costs associated with upkeep may outweigh any financial benefits.

In conclusion, while above ground pools offer convenience and affordability for those looking for a temporary swimming solution during hot summer months, there are several drawbacks that could make them less appealing over time. The limitations on size and capacity coupled with maintenance difficulties can result in high expenses down the line.

It is important to weigh these factors against personal preferences before deciding whether an above ground pool is right for you. As the saying goes, ‘all that glitters is not gold’ – meaning appearances can be deceiving; it is crucial to consider all aspects carefully before investing in such a significant addition to your property.

Bryan Mallory

My name is Bryan Mallory and I have over 25 years of experience in swimming pool, spa maintenance and repairs. With my experience and knowledge I can return your pool back to its best and keep it in peak condition.